Criticism of “seeker-sensitive” and “purpose-driven” Churches

From Auster’s VFR: Campus Crusade for Christ has changed its name …… to Cru.</a>

A. Roebuck writes:

Seeker-centered. (Also called “seeker-sensitive” and “purpose-driven.”)

The term was coined to describe the general approach made popular by Rick Warren of Saddleback Church here in Southern California, an approach that is, unfortunately, being practiced in hundreds of thousands of Protestant Churches around the world.

I had an essay on it published at American Thinker. It’s called “Seeker-Sensitive Conservatism.” An excerpt:

The purpose-driven movement begins with the premise that the only way to attract non-Christians to church is by offering to meet their felt needs, rather than their real need for salvation through Christ. If a non-Christian “seeker” visits a church where he hears the traditional Gospel message that he is a lost sinner in need of a salvation that can only come from personal repentance and trust in the atoning death of Christ, he will be repelled by the challenging message, and will not return. To prevent this failure, so the theory goes, a church must conduct market research into what people in its area want, and then find a way to give these seekers what they want.

One result is that the deep and challenging teachings of traditional Christianity must never be presented in the Sunday morning worship service that has traditionally been the cornerstone of Christian fellowship. Not only will non-Christian seekers probably not want to hear that God regards them as sinners, but they will have no interest in what Warren (and theological liberals) dismissively call “doctrine,” that is, the actual content of the religion preached by Christ and the Apostles. The result is a Christianity that retains the rituals and some of the language of traditional Protestant Christianity, but is effectively stripped of its content.

In a typical Sunday morning worship service at a typical seeker-sensitive church, attendees experience the following:

-Professionally-produced “praise music” that expresses emotions, but contains little theology, that is, little articulation of sometimes-difficult religious truths.

-A sermon that emphasizes how faith in God can make your life better, but does not mention the troubling idea that God is angry with sinners, and demands repentance and faith in Jesus in order for His wrath to be averted.

-A liturgy (form of worship) that embodies current standards of popular decorum and entertainment rather than pointing people to a transcendent God.

-Children’s programs that entertain (albeit in a quasi-Christian mode) rather than push the youth to learn challenging doctrines.

What the purpose-driven movement offers, in short, is a religious product for religious consumers, people who want a certain amount of religiosity in their lives, but who don’t want to be troubled by the full measure of Christianity.


One Comment on “Criticism of “seeker-sensitive” and “purpose-driven” Churches”

  1. umbach6 says:

    Well said. I think that saddest part of this kind of Christianity is that it looses the beauty and power of who God is and the magnitude of what He has done for us. Doctrine is not cold and out of date but life giving. Thanks for the post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s